Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Medicare Should Develop ACOs, Report Says

By David Pittman, Washington Correspondent, MedPage Today
Published: April 30, 2013

WASHINGTON -- Medicare should move to accountable care-like organizations where providers receive a globally capitated payment for their patients and must meet quality measures for full payment, health policy experts said.
A group of experts released a plan late Monday that called for creating "Medicare Comprehensive Care," organizations that collaborate to oversee the treatment of a patient.
The initial benchmark for capitated payments under the plan would be based on current beneficiary spending and quality measures, the plan from the Engelberg Center for Health Care Reform at the Brookings Institution, said. Payments would increase only at the rate of growth in gross domestic product, and providers would be expected to sustain or improve quality over time.
Beneficiaries who receive care in the model would receive lower copays and premiums, while savings in the program would go to repealing Medicare's sustainable growth rate formula, which determines physician reimbursement.
"Medicare and the rest of our health care system are not yet on sound footing from either a quality or cost standpoint, and we risk a future of continued reliance on short-term cost controls or cost shifting that have not, and cannot, get us to more sustainable, innovative care," former Senator Majority Leader Tom Daschle (D-N.D.) and report co-author, said in a news release.
Other notable co-authors included former Health and Human Services Secretary Michael Leavitt, former Congressional Budget Office Director Peter Orszag, and former Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Administrator Mark McClellan, MD, PhD.
Their third report in the "Bending the Curve" series also offers reforms for Medicaid and the private health insurance market. It was funded by a grant from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
Their changes would save around $300 billion in federal spending in the next decade and more than $1 trillion over 20 years, they project.
"We didn't come into this looking to change just one piece of the system based on our own personal agendas or beliefs," said Leavitt, a Republican, former Utah governor and founder of the Salt Lake City-based health consulting firm Leavitt Partners.
In Medicaid, CMS should make greater use of its waiver system to encourage states to develop innovative delivery and care models. States that improve quality while lowering costs would keep a share of the savings they generate. Such a move would further incentivize states to create cost-saving reforms.
In the private sector, employers should adopt practices that promote value-based purchasing and redesign insurance plans to encourage the use of more cost-effective providers through cost sharing tools, the report suggested.
Other notable reforms proposed include:
·         Performance measures from Medicare, Medicaid, and private payers should be transparent
·         Payment reforms adopted by Medicare and Medicaid should match those used in the private sector
·         Medical liability should be revamped to promote safe harbors who achieve high quality and safety performance
·         Antitrust enforcement should be updated to favor clinical integration and supports reforms away from fee-for-service
System-wide changes offered include revising scope-of-practice laws to allow health professionals to practice at the top of their license and removing barriers to telemedicine.
"Our proposals can and should be considered as part of any policy reform debate about health care," the report stated. "Whether or not a 'grand bargain' on deficit reduction and entitlement reform comes together in the near term, the general principles behind our proposals are likely to remain relevant in the future."
David Pittman is MedPage Today’s Washington Correspondent, following the intersection of policy and healthcare. He covers Congress, FDA, and other health agencies in Washington, as well as major healthcare events. David holds bachelors’ degrees in journalism and chemistry from the University of Georgia and previously worked at the Amarillo Globe-News in Texas, Chemical & Engineering News and most recently FDAnews.

PPACA exchanges crash health earnings calls

April 30, 2013

Some health insurance issuer and broker executives seem to have been talking more about the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) health insurance exchange program than about net income during their companies' first-quarter earnings calls.

Mark Bertolini, the president of Aetna Inc. (NYSE:AET), and Gary Lauer, the chief executive officer (CEO) of eHealth Inc. (Nasdaq:EHTH), are two examples of executives who answered many questions about the PPACA exchanges during their companies' calls.

PPACA requires the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) to work with state agencies to set up exchanges, or Web-based insurance supermarkets, in all 50 states and the District of Columbia by Oct. 1.
Executives at WellPoint Inc. (NYSE:WLP) have suggested that their company will try to sell through the exchange in every state in which the company has a Blue Cross or Blue Shield license.

Executives at UnitedHealth Group Inc. (NYSE:UNH) have talked about taking a "selective" approach to getting exchange slots.

Bertolini said Aetna hopes to get slots in 14 states.
For exchange programs, Aetna will use provider networks that are only one-quarter to one-half the size of its normal health plan networks, Bertolini said.
Aetna expects many early individual exchange users to be low-income and moderate-income people who qualify for subsidies, and it is expecting typical small groups to shift toward some kind of PPACA exchange or private exchange program only gradually, Bertolini said.

In theory, employers could shift 5 million employees and dependents into the exchanges by 2016, "but that's going to depend on how well these things work," Bertolini said.

During the earnings call for eHealth, the parent of the eHealthInsurance.com commercial health insurance exchange site, Lauer said that eHealth wants to have the ability to feed consumers into exchange programs throughout the United States, and that the company is hoping that HHS and managers of state-run exchanges will want to use eHealth to help with enrollment.

EHealthInsurance.com is an insurance broker, and it generates revenue by charging consumers membership fees and by collecting commissions from health insurers and other insurers.

"We can pre-enroll people," Lauer said. "We bear all that cost."

Some people in goverment "think that they're going to build the next Facebook or Google of the health insurance marketplace and that everyone will come," Lauer said. "I think I know a little bit better about that."

But most officials seem to be open to the idea of working with eHealth, Lauer said.

Today, some exchanges are talking about paying enrollers about $58 per exchange enrollee, Lauer said.
"That's expensive, and I'll be surprised if you can even do it for $58," Lauer said. "We cost nothing."

Lauer said his company was getting an average commission of about 10 percent of premiums two years ago, and that industry commission shifts cut the average to 7 percent.

In the Medicare Advantage market, the company is earning an average commission of 3 percent of premium revenue, Lauer said.

Earnings
Executives also talked about earnings during the earnings calls.

- Aetna is reporting $491 million in net income for the first quarter on $9.5 billion in revenue, compared with $511 million in net income on $8.9 billion in revenue for the first quarter of 2012.

The company ended the quarter providing or administering coverage for 18 million people, up 2 percent from the total recorded a year earlier. Commercial plan enrollment held steady at about 16 million.

- Health Net Inc. (NYSE:HNT) is reporting $50 million in net income for the first quarter on $2.8 billion in revenue, compared with a net loss of $8.1 million on $2.8 billion in revenue for the first quarter of 2012. 

The company ended the quarter providing or administering coverage for 2.5 million people, about as many people as it was covering the year before. Commercial insured plan enrollment fell 11 percent, to 1.1 million.

- Molina Healthcare Inc. (NYSE:MOH), a government plan insurer, is reporting $30 million in net income for the first quarter on $1.6 billion in revenue, compared with $18 million in net income on $1.4 billion in revenue for the first quarter of 2012.

Medical plan enrollment held steady at 1.8 million.

- EHealth is reporting $2.4 million in net income for the first quarter on $43 million in revenue, compared with $2.1 million in net income on $37 million in revenue for the first quarter of 2012.

Commission revenue increased to $38 million, from 31 million. 


President on Obamacare: 'Still A Big Complicated Piece Of Business'

Apr 30, 2013
Here is a transcript of President Barack Obama's remarks on health care during his news conference today:
CHUCK TODD, NBC NEWS: Max Baucus, Democratic senator, referred to the implementation of your health-care as a potential train wreck. (We've had ?) other Democrats been whispering nervousness about the implementation and the impact -- (inaudible) -- the impact that it might have on their own political campaigns in 2014. Why do you keep -- just curious, why does Senator Baucus, somebody who extensively helped write your bill, believe that this is going to be a train wreck? And why do you believe he's wrong?
PRESIDENT OBAMA: Well, I -- you know, I think that any time you're implementing something big, there is going to be people who are nervous and anxious about is it going to get done until it's actually done. But -- but let's just step back for a second and -- and -- and make sure the American people understand what it is that we're doing. The Affordable Care Act, 'Obamacare,' has now been with us for three years. It's gone through Supreme Court tests. It's gone through efforts to repeal. A huge chunk of it's already been implemented.
And for the 85 to 90 percent of Americans who already have health insurance, they're already experiencing most of the benefits of the Affordable Care Act even if they don't know it. Their insurance is more secure. Insurance companies can't drop them for bad reasons. Their kids are able to stay on their health insurance until they're 26 years old. They're getting free preventive care.
On The Capsules Blog
So there are a whole host of benefits that -- for the average American out there, for the 85 to 90 percent of Americans who already have health insurance, this thing's already happened, and their only impact is that their insurance is stronger, better, more secure than it was before. Full stop. That's it. Now they don't have to worry about anything else.
The implementation issues come in for those who don't have health insurance, maybe because they have a pre-existing condition and the only way they can get health insurance is to go out on the individual market and they're paying 50 percent or a hundred percent more than those of us who are lucky enough to have group plans. People who are too poor to get health insurance and the employers don't offer them. Maybe they work for a small business and that small business can't afford right now to provide health insurance.
So all the implementation issues that are coming up are implementation issues related to that small group of people, 10 to 15 percent of Americans -- now, it's still 30 million Americans, but relatively narrow group -- who don't have health insurance right now or are on the individual market and are paying exorbitant amounts for coverage that isn't that great.
And what we're doing is we're setting up a pool so that they can all pool together and get a better deal from insurance companies. And those who can't afford it, we're going to provide them with some subsidies. That's it. I mean, that's what's left to implement because the other stuff's been implemented and it's working fine.
The challenge is that, you know, setting up a market-based system, basically an online marketplace where you can go on and sign up and figure out what kind of insurance you can afford and figuring out how to get the subsidies, that's still a big complicated piece of business. 
And when you're doing it nationwide, relatively fast, and you've got half of Congress who is determined to try to block implementation and not adequately funding implementation, and then you've got a number of members of -- or governors -- Republican governors who know that it's bad politics for them to try to implement this effectively -- and some even who have decided to implement it and then their Republican-controlled state legislatures say don't implement and won't pass enabling legislation -- when you have that kind of situation, that makes it harder.
But having said all that, we've got a great team in place. We are pushing very hard to make sure that we're hitting all the deadlines and the benchmarks. I'll give you an example -- a recent example. You know, we put together initially an application form for signing up for participation in the exchanges that was initially about 21 pages long.
And immediately everybody sat around the table and said: 'Well, this is too long, especially, you know, in this age of the Internet. People aren't going to have the patience to sit there for hours on end. Let's streamline this thing.'
So we cut what was a 21-page form now down to a form that's about three pages for an individual, a little more than that for a family, well below the industry average. So those kinds of refinements, we're going to continue to be working on.
But I think the main message I want to give to the American people here is despite all the hue and cry and, you know, sky-is-falling predictions about this stuff, if you've already got health insurance, then that part of "Obamacare" that affects you, it's pretty much already in place. And that's about 85 percent of the country.
What is left to be implemented is those provisions to help the 10 to 15 percent of the American public that is unlucky enough that they don't have health insurance. And by the way, you know, some of you who have health insurance right now, at some point you may lose your health insurance, and if you've got a pre-existing condition, this structure will make sure that you are not left vulnerable.
But it's still a big undertaking. And what we're doing is making sure that every single day we are constantly trying to hit our marks so that it will be in place.
And -- and the last point I'll make, even if we do everything perfectly, there'll still be, you know, glitches and bumps, and there'll be stories that can be written that says, oh, look, this thing's, you know, not working the way it's supposed to, and this happened and that happened. And that's pretty much true of every government program that's ever been set up.
But if we stay with it and we understand what our long-term objective is, which is making sure that in a country as wealthy as ours, nobody should go bankrupt if they get sick and that we would rather have people getting regular checkups than going to the emergency room because they don't have health care -- if -- if we keep that in mind, then we're going to be able to drive down costs, we're going to be able to improve efficiencies in the system, we're going to be able to see people benefit form better health care, and that will save the country money as a whole over the long term.
QUESTION: Do you think without the cooperation of a handful of governors, particularly large states like Florida and Texas, that you can fully implement it?
PRESIDENT OBAMA: I think it's harder; there's no doubt about it.
QUESTION: But can you do it without those?
PRESIDENT OBAMA: We -- we will implement it. There will be -- we have a backup federal exchange. If states aren't cooperating, we set up a federal exchange, so that people can access that federal exchange.
But yes, it puts more of a burden on us. And it's ironic, since all these folks say that they believe in empowering states, that they're going to end up having the federal government do something that we'd actually prefer states to do if they were properly cooperating.

Hospital CEO, CFO and MDs Arrested Over Alleged Kickbacks for Medicare Patients

Reprinted from REPORT ON MEDICARE COMPLIANCE, the nation's leading source of news and strategic information on Medicare compliance, Stark and other big-dollar issues of concern to health care compliance officers.
By Nina Youngstrom, Managing Editor
April 22, 2013 Volume 22 Issue 14
The CEO and CFO of a Chicago hospital were arrested on April 16 in connection with an alleged scheme to pay physicians for patient referrals, according to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Northern District of Illinois.
CEO Edward Novak, owner and CEO of 119-bed Sacred Heart Hospital, CFO Roy Payawal and four affiliated physicians were charged with violating the federal anti-kickback law. Their alleged malfeasance was recorded by “cooperating witnesses” at the request of government agents, according to a 90-page FBI affidavit filed in support of the criminal complaint. The cooperating witnesses were a physician, who was then-chairman of emergency room operations, and Administrator A and Administrator B, both members of the senior executive staff. Administrators A and B recorded in-person and telephone conversations with Sacred Heart executives, physicians and employees, the affidavit says.
The thrust of the complaint is that the hospital carried out a plan to pay physicians kickbacks for their referrals of Medicare and Medicaid patients, allegedly at the direction of the CEO and CFO. Alleged kickbacks were concealed in “fictitious rental payments” that the hospital made to physicians for office space it never used; salaries for the physicians’ employees (e.g., physician assistants); “ghost contracts” to physicians (e.g., medical directorships without duties); and payments to physicians to train and supervise nonexistent medical students.
“Sacred Heart’s efforts to recruit physicians willing to sell their patient referrals to the hospital were openly discussed among the hospital’s executive staff,” Administrator A and B said, according to the affidavit. “For example, on April 10, 2012, Administrator B consensually recorded a meeting with Payawal and Administrator A in which Administrator B inquired about the types of ‘incentives’ Sacred Heart could offer prospective referring physicians.”
The feds executed search and seizure warrants in connection with the investigation, which is ongoing. The FBI affidavit states that “the investigation extends to allegations of unnecessary emergency room admissions.” Meanwhile, the government seized about $2 million from bank accounts that had been collected in Medicare reimbursement.
“The arrests should send a chilling message both to health care executives and physicians: If you pay or accept kickbacks, big trouble follows,” says former federal prosecutor Michael A. Hirst, with Hirst Law Group in Davis, Calif.
Hospital Recently Settled EMTALA Case
Interestingly, in mid-February, Sacred Heart settled a civil monetary penalty case with the HHS Office of Inspector General for $50,000 over an alleged violation of the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act. The settlement, which was signed by the now-arrested Novak, alleged that the hospital failed to screen a 63-year-old woman when she presented at the emergency room last year. Her companion said she was not breathing, but the hospital allegedly called the fire department to transport her to another hospital, “where she was pronounced dead,” according to the settlement. Sacred Heart did not admit liability.
If compliance officers work at hospitals where there is a whiff that senior management may be engaging in illegal arrangements, they may feel hopeless, says Albany attorney Robert Hussar, with Manatt, Phelps & Phillips. “If senior management is involved in a scheme, it makes a compliance officer’s job much more challenging. But there are still things you can do,” he says, including:
·         Educate staff about potential instances of noncompliance. “Make sure they know their obligation to come forward,” Hussar says.
·         Ensure you have an active auditing and monitoring program. “It needs to do more than look at the four corners of a document,” he says. For example, when paychecks are given to physicians for space the hospital leases, go check the space. Is it truly the number of square feet paid for in the lease? Is it used for the purpose stated in the contract? And look behind medical directorships and other personal service arrangements. Did the physicians really perform the job duties as set forth in the contract, and did they work the required number of hours? Is that particular medical directorship even necessary or is it used to reward a physician for loyalty to the hospital? “You need to kick the tires on arrangements,” he says.
If something isn’t right, compliance officers should go directly to their board of directors if senior management is involved, Hussar says.
Sacred Heart Hospital spokeswoman Jessica Thunberg said the hospital is cooperating with law enforcement and has no other information on the FBI investigation. But, she said, the Illinois Department of Public Health visited the hospital on April 17 and reviewed its ability to care for patients. “Following that visit, Sacred Heart Hospital continues to accept patients and provide care,” she said, and the chief nursing officer is now acting administrator. Lawyers for the CEO and CFO did not return RMC’s calls for comment.
To read the press release, visit http://tinyurl.com/cpfes4d.

Will Money Motivate More Fraud Tipsters?

By Francie Fernald - April 26, 2013
The Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services is taking a cue from the generous whistleblower rewards that have prompted the rapid growth of False Claims Act cases alleging health care fraud and an Internal Revenue Service program designed to motivate individuals to report tax fraud, which has collected almost $1.6 billion and paid about $193 million in rewards over a five-year period.
In a proposed rule issued April 24 and published in the April 29 Federal Register, CMS said it would dramatically overhaul its existing individual reward program (IRP) with an eye towards improving recoveries from Medicare fraud reported by individuals. Currently, CMS rewards a tipster with up to $1,000 if the tip results in a recovery. But this program, which was instituted in 1998, has paid less than $16,000 on 18 rewards over its 15-year life — hardly a drop in the bucket compared to the IRS program.
If the rule is finalized as proposed, CMS would pay 15% of the first $66 million recovered to a person who provides information about a specific individual engaging in specific activities during a specific time period. The reward could amount to as much as $9.9 million. By upping the potential reward, CMS hopes more people will monitor the claims submitted to Medicare and learn how to detect and report fraud.
What impact do you think this change in the IRP will have on fraud reporting? Will it have an impact on the number of FCA cases filed?

Today's Datapoint

$3.8 million … was awarded by a jury to a California doctor who was excluded from the provider network of WellPoint Inc.-owned Anthem Blue Cross

Quote of the Day

“I do think [the $500 million jury award against UnitedHealth Group for allegedly not monitoring the quality of care of its physician networks] sends a signal to health plans to have some responsibility about who they accept into their network. This case … could be part of a new wave of litigation against health plans to make sure they are living up to their responsibilities. After all, they do market health plans as providing quality medical care, making a promise to subscribers and members.”

— William Shernoff, attorney with the California law firm of Shernoff Bidart & Darras, told AIS’s Health Plan Week.