Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Nondiscriminatory PPACA provisions could cost employers

April 30, 2013

Health care exchanges are getting all of the attention, but employers need to take a closer look at their benefits packages because the nondiscriminatory provision of PPACA has the potential to cost them a lot of money.

So says Jay Starkman, the CEO of Engage PEO, a human resources outsourcing organization.
Under the provision, employers can no longer give preferential treatment when it comes to benefit plans. Everyone must have the same benefit options. The new provision is set to go into effect in January 2014, though this could be delayed as more guidance is scheduled to come down.
“It doesn’t sound like a big deal, but when you take into account two very common practices that businesses have been following for years that would violate this provision, it really becomes meaningful, especially when you couple that with the penalties that are built into the act,” Starkman said.
In one case, an employer would violate this provision if it pays for a greater portion of benefits for C-suite employees than others, Starkman said.

Often, executives build agreements into their contracts that their benefits are covered at a higher level or their families might receive coverage while the spouses and children of everyone else working for the company are not.
Another practice that could get an employer into trouble is basing benefits on tenure, Starkman said.

As an employee builds years of service, some employers provide a more robust benefit offering. Although the intention may be to reward that employee for his or her service, it could lead to trouble under PPACA, and both of these instances come with stiff fines.
“If you have 101 employees in your company and one employee, the CEO, is getting all of his benefits paid for and the other 100 are not, those other 100 employees start accumulating a penalty at $100 a day, which comes to $10,000 a day,” Starkman said. “Now, there’s a cap on this at half a million dollars, but if you’re at a larger company that practices this for the entire C-suite, you could be at half a million dollars in a matter of days.”
Not every type of benefit is covered under this provision, which only applies to health care coverage, notes Bruce Elliott, manager of benefits and compensation for the Society of Human Resource Management.

Executives often have premium life and disability benefits, and those higher tiers are still allowed under ACA.

Obama administration simplifies health care form

April 30, 2013

WASHINGTON — The first draft was as mind-numbing and complex as tax forms. Now the Obama administration is unveiling a simplified application for health insurance benefits under the federal health care overhaul.

Details to be released Tuesday include a three-page short form that single people can fill out, administration officials said. Medicare chief Marilyn Tavenner, also overseeing the rollout of the health care law, called it "significantly shorter than industry standards."
The earlier draft of the application was widely panned, and administration allies feared uninsured people would give up in frustration. Administration officials say they have trimmed the paperwork burden back considerably.
One activist briefed on the changes said Monday the administration has made big improvements. Ron Pollack, executive director of Families USA, said the new application will be easier to navigate and much less intimidating.
Although the new forms may be shorter, it's unclear whether the administration can get rid of all the complexity. That's because applicants will have to provide detailed snapshots of their incomes to see whether they qualify for government assistance. Individuals will have to gather tax returns, pay stubs and other financial records before filling out the application.
Nearly 30 million uninsured Americans are eventually expected to get coverage through President Barack Obama's health care law. Enrollment starts Oct. 1 for coverage that takes effect Jan. 1. Middle-class people who don't get coverage through their jobs will be able to purchase private insurance, in most cases with the help of tax credits to make premiums more affordable. Low-income uninsured people will be steered to government programs like Medicaid.
Administration officials expect most consumers to apply online through new health insurance marketplaces that will be operating in each state. A single application form will serve to route consumers to either private plans or the Medicaid program. Identification, citizenship and immigration status, as well as income details, are supposed to be verified in close to real time through a federal "data hub" that will involve pinging Social Security, Homeland Security and the Internal Revenue Service.
Currently, applying for health insurance individually entails filling out a lengthy questionnaire about your health. Under Obama's overhaul, insurers will no longer be able to turn away the sick, or charge them more. The health care questions will disappear, but they'll be replaced by questions about your income. Consumers who underestimate their incomes could be in for an unwelcome surprise later on in the form of smaller tax refunds.

Family Values and the Irony of the ACA

Apr 29 2013 10:23 pm

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) endeavors to help millions of Americans obtain medical insurance. Some supporters are compelled by compassion, others by business interest, but the idea of helping more people get insured is now widely supported. However, federal regulations have introduced what appears to be a significant disconnect between the intent to cover everyone and the employment regulations that will determine whether lower wage workers can actually afford coverage.
Low wage families will be looking for the most affordable coverage options for the entire family. If income is low enough, the entire family may be eligible for Medicaid in some states. Under Medicaid, the family may have no monthly premium cost, and out-of-pocket costs would be nominal. However, if the family is above the Medicaid and/or Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) eligibility thresholds, private coverage may be the only option. So will anyone subsidize private coverage for families that are above Medicaid/CHIP income thresholds?
Either the employer or the government may help. Federal law encourages the employer to take the lead in premium support, but the law doesn’t require it. If the employer doesn’t offer some kind of coverage and employer contribution, an excise tax (employer penalty) may be applied except with the small employers (less than 50 full-time equivalent employees) as they are exempt. As a fallback, the government is offering advanced premium tax credits (APTC) to the worker and/or family members who cannot access “affordable” coverage at work. But what is “affordable,” and how does the affordability standard apply to a family?
As a fallback, the government is offering advanced premium tax credits (APTC) to the worker and/or family members who cannot access “affordable” coverage at work. But what is “affordable,” and how does the affordability standard apply to a family?
Group coverage is deemed affordable (for purposes of eligibility for the APTC) if the “single only” coverage is available to a worker at a cost less than 9.5% of the employee’s household income. Employers must offer coverage to dependents (recently defined as children, not a spouse) to avoid employer penalties, but the employer is not required or expected to pay for dependent coverage. As a result, many low wage workers will end up in a situation where the employer pays toward employee-only group coverage, while offering dependent coverage on the worker’s dime. Because dependent coverage (which is deemed affordable even though it may not be) is available to the worker’s family through the group plan, the family members are not eligible for APTC help from the government if applying for coverage in the public exchange. At the end of the day, many workers will be unable to afford the cost of family coverage at work and will leave their dependents uninsured.
An unintended consequence may arise in the labor market. If the large employer does not pay a substantial portion (in my opinion, at least a majority) of the family coverage for low wage workers, the employee will eventually figure out that the only way to get financial assistance to cover their dependent children will be to find work with an employer that does not offer “affordable” coverage. This will probably lead to an incentive for low wage employers to either drop group coverage, or “engineer” the employee-only cost of the group plan to be more that 9.5% of W-2 wages for low wage workers.
In either case, the large employer will pay a penalty, and the employee may remain eligible for APTC financial assistance in the public exchange for himself and any dependents.
Engineering the single-only cost of the group plan to something exceeding 9.5% of W-2 wages may end up making the most sense for the employer. The corporation is able to indirectly leverage the APTC to make sure family members are covered since employees could waive group coverage and take the government subsidies instead. The employer’s excise tax (employer penalty) won’t deter this strategy as the penalty will be comparable to what the employer would have spent on single-only coverage.
The downside will be the challenges that employer may have with participation requirements on the group plan, which may be imposed either by the carrier based on market rules (for fully insured plans), or by Treasury guidance. IRC 105(h) imposes certain discrimination rules on group health plans in order for those plans to remain tax advantaged, and part of the forthcoming rules from the Treasury may include certain group participation thresholds. If participation requirements for group plans prevent the “engineered” strategy of pushing lower wage people away from the group plan and into the public exchange, many low wage employers may drop their group plans out of necessity in order to recruit labor

Obama budget signals quicker trigger on Medicare pay cuts

 Physicians and hospitals express concerns about the White House budget's potential impact on pay, including a provision to accelerate work of a Medicare cost-cutting board.
By Jennifer Lubell amednews staff — Posted April 22, 2013
Washington Medical organizations hailed the Obama administration's efforts to boost mental and public health in its fiscal 2014 budget proposal, but provisions in the blueprint to achieve additional savings in Medicare sounded alarms about the possible impact on payment rates.
The White House's yearly budget blueprint, released April 9, provides a template for the administration as it negotiates with Congress on spending levels for departments and agencies. Lawmakers on Capitol Hill are not required to act on anything the administration proposes, and subsequent disputes during the authorization and appropriations phases often lead to short-term spending measures to keep the federal government operating, typically at the same funding levels as the previous year.
In this year's proposal, President Obama is attempting to offer middle ground between Republican interests in deep cuts to federal spending and Democratic efforts to raise revenues. Under his $3.8 trillion budget for the next fiscal year, Obama said he would replace the across-the-board sequester cuts that went into effect on March 1 with “smarter ones” that would eliminate waste to government programs, reducing the deficit by nearly $2 trillion over 10 years. As part of this strategy, the administration proposed a series of improvements that aims to reduce health spending by roughly $400 billion, with most of the net savings in Medicare. This would put the program “on a stable financial trajectory,” Kathleen Sebelius, Health and Human Services secretary, said during an April 9 teleconference. Medicare spending per beneficiary grew just 0.4% in 2012 in part due to provisions in the Affordable Care Act, she said. “Even more savings will be reached under this budget proposal.”
Mandating new Medicare drug rebates from pharmaceutical companies accounts for a large portion of these savings, although about a third of the net savings would come from provisions that affect physicians, hospitals and other health care professionals, according to an analysis by Washington consulting firm Avalere Health LLC.
The White House budget would delay cuts until 2015 to what Medicaid pays hospitals for treating more indigent patients, but it also would set more ambitious targets for an outside panel authorized by the ACA and charged with keeping down Medicare spending growth rates.
The Medicare Independent Payment Advisory Board would recommend policies for fast-track congressional consideration that would reduce growth rates in the event Medicare spending projections exceeded certain predetermined targets. To strengthen IPAB's charter for reducing long-term cost growth, the Obama budget proposes to lower the target rate of Medicare spending per beneficiary from 1% above the nation's gross domestic product to 0.5%. This is not a new proposal, but its inclusion in the budget means Obama continues to push for it.
Although the president is telegraphing some willingness to restrain Medicare and Medicaid spending, Republicans on Capitol Hill gave the document a cool reception, insisting the savings were too minimal. “The president's program takes only baby steps in reforming our entitlement programs,” Sen. Orrin Hatch (R, Utah), lead Republican on the Senate Finance Committee, said during a recent hearing.
Renewed calls for IPAB repeal
Physician organizations also gave the White House budget mixed reviews. The administration is committed to repealing Medicare's sustainable growth rate formula and replacing it with a system that encourages doctors to provide more efficient, higher-quality care. Such an approach would allow for several years of stable payments to give physicians time to adapt to new, accountable payment models. Jeremy A. Lazarus, MD, president of the American Medical Association, said the AMA was pleased that the administration supported SGR repeal and the move toward more value-based payment models.
But the budget “takes a step backward” by setting another arbitrary spending target for the Medicare IPAB, he said, a move that could mean deeper pay cuts for doctors. The AMA and others in organized medicine strongly support bipartisan IPAB repeal legislation, likening the IPAB to the SGR formula, another provision in Medicare statute that arbitrarily threatens cuts to doctor payments.
The encouraging news is that health care spending growth “has been well below projections so that the goals of the IPAB in savings are happening without the need for their intervention,” said M. Eugene Sherman, MD, chair of the American College of Cardiology Advocacy Steering Committee. But given the uncertainties that still surround the operations of this board, the ACC does not support lowering IPAB's threshold for action, he said.
Hospitals expressed their own warnings about certain provisions of the blueprint. While appreciative of the administration's proposal to delay reductions to the disproportionate share hospital payments that help cover care for poor patients who can't afford their bills, “we're concerned the delay comes at the expense of higher DSH cuts the following two years and a $3.6 billion baseline adjustment in 2023,” said Bruce Siegel, MD, MPH, president and CEO of the National Assn. of Public Hospitals and Health Systems.
Another area of concern for hospitals was the budget's measure to reduce Medicare's coverage of bad medical debt from 65% to 25% over three years. The administration's reasoning is that private payers typically don't cover unpaid amounts owed by beneficiaries. By bringing Medicare policy more in line with how private insurers operate, the White House estimates that the program could save more than $25 billion over 10 years.
For hospitals, less federal support on bad debt means higher uncompensated care costs, said Blair Childs, senior vice president of public affairs with the Premier health care alliance. The facilities are not going to get that money back, so this effectively is a cut, he said.
In his statement, Dr. Siegel cautioned lawmakers to weigh these Medicare cost savings “against their potential to financially burden beneficiaries and their providers.” The bad-debt provision, as well as the administration's proposed cuts to Medicare medical education payments, “would weaken the ability of hospitals to provide comprehensive services to communities and to train the next generation of physicians, nurses and allied health professionals,” he said.
The $11 billion in proposed cuts for Medicare graduate medical education funding received pushback from doctors' organizations as well. “In 2013, 528 U.S. medical school seniors failed to match to a residency program. As the nation deals with a physician shortage, it is important that all medical students can complete their training and care for patients,” the AMA's Dr. Lazarus said.
Budget would bolster public health
Glen Stream, MD, chair of the American Academy of Family Physicians board of directors, also expressed concerns about the proposed reductions to medical education. But several of the Obama budget's proposals deserve support, he said.
In particular, he commended the inclusion of a plan to raise tobacco taxes to reduce use of these products. “Experience has demonstrated that increased taxes on tobacco products inhibit the use of tobacco, especially among teenagers and young adults who haven't started smoking or using other tobacco products,” Dr. Stream said.
Physicians also supported the administration's continued efforts to boost awareness of and treatment for mental health problems in teenagers and young adults. The HHS portion of the budget calls for a $130 million investment to train 5,000 additional health care professionals, educate teachers and other adults on the signs of mental illness, and offer counseling services to young people. The budget also earmarks $30 million for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to create a national “violent death” surveillance system, as well as for additional research on gun violence.
In light of the December 2012 shootings at Sandy Point Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., the American Academy of Pediatrics said funding for more research and training would help improve safety in schools and communities. “Pediatricians now charge Congress with expanding upon the president's plan by proposing bigger, bolder policies to provide children, adolescents and young adults with access to high-quality, affordable mental health services,” said AAP President Thomas K. McInerny, MD.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
White House targets some doctor, hospital pay
Much of the $400 billion in net, 10-year health care savings in President Obama's fiscal 2014 budget proposal would come from larger Medicare drug rebates from pharmaceutical companies. However, a significant portion of the savings also would come from provisions that affect doctors, hospitals and other health professionals.

The rise of voluntary

10 Years, 10 Catalysts of Change in Benefits
April 25, 2013

You might call it the rise of voluntary benefits. The game changer in benefits offerings. Call it whatever you want, but voluntary benefits have exploded in recent years.
A decade ago, voluntary products were mainly offered by large employers as a way to both increase engagement as well as curb the rising cost of health care—after all, voluntary benefits can be added by employers for no extra cost.
But today, organizations of all sizes are broadening their menu of voluntary benefits to offset coverage gaps, especially as employers further reduce their contributions to cut costs.
“In our current environment, voluntary benefits deliver the same benefits they did a decade ago, but they serve a much broader audience,” explains Robert Risk, senior vice president of group protection sales and distribution at Lincoln Financial Group.
Most industry experts will call voluntary products a win-win-win. They happily serve companies, employees and brokers alike.
Though the rising cost of health care, coupled with the weak economy, has spurred companies to add voluntary benefits, they are also turning to voluntary to attract and retain skilled employees.
And employees love the option of pet insurance or legal insurance and other benefits they might not have thought of. According to a Hartford study, employees who are offered voluntary benefits reported higher satisfaction with their benefits than did those who were not offered voluntary products (64 percent and 56 percent, respectively).
And of course, these voluntary products are intended to most benefit the holders of the product economically. “Over the last decade, wages have not kept pace with household needs and families often rely on two incomes,” Risk says. “This has increased their vulnerability to events that disrupt their cash flow. More expensive medical insurance with higher deductibles only worsens the situation. Voluntary benefits can help employees close these gaps at little or no cost to employers.”
Let’s not forget, too, that voluntary benefits are especially important to brokers as they look for new revenue streams with health reform changes. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act’s medical loss ratio spells out changes that may hit a broker’s bottom line hard, unless they consider new ways of doing business. Out of every premium dollar, 85 cents has to be used to pay claims, leaving 15 cents to pay for carrier expenses, including broker commissions.
Introducing voluntary products might literally save some brokers their job. “Brokers are now deciding whether to cut staff or services, or merge with other brokers,” Steve Hannah, regional vice president of group benefit services at Mutual of Omaha, told Benefits Selling in December. “There’s also a mass influx of brokers, and some are now calling themselves voluntary benefit experts.”
The coming years—especially with further implementation of health reform—will only mainstream voluntary products more, experts agree.
So it might be a good idea to brush up on critical illness/cancer, accident, disability, life, long-term care, vision and dental insurance—just to name a few.

New IRS affordability proposal excludes employer wellness discounts

May 1, 2013 - 2:33pm
Top of Form
Employers generally would not be allowed to include health care plan premium contribution discounts they offer employees who participate in wellness programs to determine if the coverage passes a health care reform law affordability test, under newly proposed Internal Revenue Service regulations.
The eagerly awaited regulations, released Tuesday, deal with one of the last major employer-related areas, for which there has been no guidance in how to comply with the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
The regulation involves the relationship between a health care plan premium affordability test, slated under the reform law to go into effect in 2014, and premium discounts employers offer employees to give them a financial incentive to participate in their wellness programs.
Under that test, coverage is considered affordable, as long as the premium paid by an employee for individual coverage does not exceed 9.5% of wages or household income. If the premium contribution exceeds that threshold, the coverage is considered “unaffordable” subjecting the employer to a $3,000 penalty.
Until now, it wasn't clear whether premium discounts some employers provide for wellness program participation would be included or excluded when running the affordability test.
One exception
Now, the IRS said premium discounts would be excluded in running the affordability test, with the exception of tobacco cessation programs.
For example, if an employee charged employees a monthly premium of $100 for single coverage if they participated in a wellness program and $120 for those that did not, employers would use the $120 premium assessment in testing whether the coverage was affordable.

Physician Compensation by Practice Setting

Academic
$187,000
Healthcare Organization
$247,000
Hospital
$260,000
Multispecialty Group Practice
$260,000
Single-Specialty Group Practice
$265,000
Solo Practice
$211,000
Outpatient Clinic
$185,000
Other
$194,000

Source: Medscape, Physician Compensation Report: 2013