Thursday, May 2, 2013

Statement From John Gorman, Executive Chairman, Gorman Health Group Regarding the Final 2014 Rates for Medicare Advantage

April 02, 2013 18:11 ET
WASHINGTON, DC--(Marketwired - April 02, 2013) -  The following is a statement from John Gorman, Executive Chairman, Gorman Health Group: 
"The last 45 days for Medicare Advantage (MA) stakeholders have been like watching an asteroid on a collision course with Earth, only to be averted at the last second. With the proposed rates representing the deepest cuts to MA in the history of the program, this was nothing less than doom diverted, a stunning reversal from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). It was a rare bipartisan coalition of over 160 Members of Congress whose lobbying power brought April flowers. Tea Partiers and the Chairman of the Congressional Progressive Caucus alike came together to get this result. Democrats, in particular, seem to have awakened to the constituency MA serves: largely lower-income minorities in greatest need of coordinated care. In response, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the White House overruled the CMS actuaries to get over 550 basis points' improvement in the final rates. It shows the new political juice MA has acquired, now serving almost 30% of Medicare beneficiaries, who overwhelmingly love it.
"The new trends for 2014 are POSITIVE 2.96% for MA rates calculated under the old law, and 3.53% for MA rates calculated under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). About half of all US counties are still getting a blend of these two rates, while the remaining counties are fully on the new ACA rates. Overall, the average increase will be around 3.3% - 3.4%, versus the 2.2% cut proposed in the advance notice.
Blending and Rebasing
"CMS rebased the county Fee For Service (FFS) costs again. This will move some counties from one quartile to another, giving some counties bigger increases, or actual decreases, based solely on the effect of rebasing. Since the impact is phased in over two years, a number of in-between quartiles develop. In theory, a county's ACA rate can be any of 24 different blends of 2012, 2013 and 2014 quartiles. In 2014 counties will be arrayed across nine different 'quartiles,' reflecting the effect of the blending due to quartile changes.
"It appears that the quartile turmoil is less this time than with the 2013 rebasing. While 27% of all counties changed quartiles with the 2013 rebasing, only 13% are changing quartiles this time.
"Rebasing can also affect whether a county qualifies for a double bonus under the quality bonus system, since one of the criteria is a county FFS cost figure that is below the national average. In 2013, four counties gained double bonus status, and seven lost it. In 2014, eighteen counties will gain double bonus status, among which are three counties regaining the double bonus after losing it in 2013. Only two counties will lose double bonus status in 2014. Plans that qualify for quality bonus payments will see those payments increase or decrease by 5% for members who live in counties gaining or losing double bonus status. This adds yet another unpredictable variable to revenue planning.
"In a change in methodology, CMS used current wage index and physician cost index data to recalculate the historical claims used in rebasing, to express FFS costs at current Medicare allowable amounts. Previously they took prior year claims as paid. This adds accuracy to the rebasing calculation, but it adds more uncertainty to rebasing for 2014. For 2014 only, CMS is blending the new calculations with the old method of not adjusting for changes in indices. The blend is 50/50, for 2014 only. This adds yet one more variable to the payment calculation process, and also strongly implies that CMS will rebase again in 2015, again moving counties among quartiles. This potential for movement among quartiles, based on FFS cost patterns outside the control of MA plans, makes long range planning difficult. Rates can vary by 5% or more from where a plan expects them to be, based on where CMS rebasing calculations peg a plan's counties' FFS costs relative to all other US counties."
Risk Adjustment Reprieve
"The MA industry dodged a bullet on risk adjustment in particular. CMS is implementing new Hierarchical Condition Categories (HCC) risk adjustment coefficients for 2014. CMS say that the new codes will result in lower risk scores than the old coefficients, given the same mix of diagnoses. The impact is projected to be approximately a 2.6% reduction in scores, on average. The actual impact on individual plans will depend on the diagnostic profile of their members. CMS have abandoned the idea proposed in the advance notice, to hold plans harmless from the impact of the change in 2014 by adjusting the denominator used in the calculations. Instead they are blending the old rates with the new ones, at 25% old and 75% new. This implies that 75% of the reduction, or about 1.95%, will be felt in 2014, while the entire 2.6% will affect 2015 risk scores. This will offset the positive impact of the rate trends, and places even more weight on plans to diligently discover, document, and report all relevant diagnoses.
"Because CMS is blending 2013 and 2014 risk scores, they have calculated two different FFS normalization scores. The FFS normalization is necessary to shift the mid-point of the HCC score structure so that it averages out to exactly 1.00 when applied to a sample of FFS claims. This isn't an adjustment for MA coding, but for changes in FFS coding over time. The two normalization factors will be blended, too. The FFS normalization scores are:
  • Applicable to the 2013 HCCs (25%) = 1.041
  • Applicable to the 2014 HCCs (75%) = 1.026
  • "Average" = 1.0298
This compares with the single normalization factor in the advance notice, of 1.026.
"The coding intensity adjustment, which takes back money to compensate for the fact that plans keep getting better at risk coding, goes up by 1.5 percentage points in 2014, from 3.41% to 4.91%. This is mandated by law, and is no surprise. This will be an added reduction in revenue, based on the assumption that plans are continually improving their ability to report diagnoses, and it is incumbent on plans to live up to that expectation, or suffer erosion of income.
"CMS is putting off for a year any attempt to address how diagnoses that are documented in health risk assessments (HRAs) affect risk adjustment. They were going to require plans to flag all diagnoses discovered in HRAs during 2013. CMS proposed to disallow codes from HRAs in future years unless they were substantiated by another clinical encounter. The difficulty is that they have not yet developed a concrete definition of an HRA, as distinct from a routine checkup. This idea isn't dead, and we expect CMS to find some way to ascertain whether data from HRAs represent actual risk. Plans must use HRAs as a mechanism to identify and manage patients at risk, with a clear handoff of HRA data to care management programs. Documentation of diseases that map to HCCs is a valuable by-product of HRAs, but should not overtake the significance of the clinical purpose of prospective exams. 
"CMS has relented somewhat on the total beneficiary cost (TBC) limit, compared to the advance notice, and it's a much lesser issue with some restoration of the rates. The TBC is the maximum amount by which CMS will allow plans to increase the combination of premiums and cost sharing, using the CMS estimate of the Per Member Per Month (PMPM) cost of any cost sharing changes. They were proposing to reduce the maximum TBC change from $36 to $30 per member-month. Now they are only reducing it to $34. Also, the TBC is adjusted for the impact of benchmark reductions caused by phase-in of the new ACA rates, including changes in quartiles, and gaining or losing double-bonus status.
"While this final notice was good news across the board, we still must recognize that, all in, we're still looking at a cut in rates in 2014 after the impact of the ACA is considered. It's just less severe than what was proposed. We'll likely see cuts like these again in 2015 and beyond. And while the Administration has shown here that they have no interest in market disruption, their knives are still out on the basis of plan performance. 
"These are just the beginning of austerity measures, and MA will only get harder to manage profitably over time. Forward-looking plans will use this stay of execution to drive needed change within their companies more urgently."
If you have additional questions or would like to schedule an interview with one of Gorman Health Group's subject matter experts, please contact Kristin Rodriguez: 510-244-7114, or krodriguez@gormanhealthgroup.com.
Thank you,
Kristin Rodriguez, Director of Marketing
Gorman Health Group

Proposed Fiscal Year 2014 Payment and Policy Changes for Medicare Inpatient Rehabilitation Facilities

FACT SHEET

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE                                            Contact: CMS Media Relations
May 2, 2013                                                                                                   (202) 690-6145


Proposed Fiscal Year 2014 Payment and Policy Changes for Medicare Inpatient Rehabilitation Facilities


Overview. On May 2, 2013, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) issued a proposed rule outlining proposed fiscal year (FY) 2014 Medicare payment policies and rates for the inpatient rehabilitation facilities (IRFs) Prospective Payment System (PPS), as well as updates and changes for the IRF Quality Reporting Program (QRP). The FY 2014 proposals are summarized below.

PROPOSED CHANGES TO IRF PAYMENT POLICIES AND RATES:

Updates to the payment rates under the IRF PPS. Based on proposed changes contained within this rule, CMS estimates that aggregate payments to IRFs will increase by $150 million, or 2.0 percent. This estimated increase is attributable to a 1.8 percent payment update, which includes a 2.5 percent market basket increase factor, reduced by a 0.4 percent multi-factor productivity adjustment and an additional 0.3 percentage point reduction as required under the Affordable Care Act. In addition, CMS is proposing an update to the outlier threshold, which would increase IRF PPS payments by an estimated 0.2 percent.  

Facility-level adjustment updates. CMS is proposing updates to the IRF facility-level rural, low-income percentage, and teaching status adjustments, including a new variable in the regression methodology to indicate whether the IRF is a freestanding hospital or a unit of an acute care hospital (or critical access hospital). The updated methodology enhances the accuracy of the adjustments. CMS continues to base the adjustments on three years’ worth of data, instead of one year, to improve the stability of the adjustments over time.

“60-percent rule” Presumptive Methodology Code List Updates In order to be excluded from the hospital inpatient PPS and be paid at the higher IRF PPS rates, an inpatient hospital must demonstrate that at least 60 percent of its patients meet the criteria specified in the regulations, including the need for intensive inpatient rehabilitation services for one or more of the 13 listed conditions, representing a presumptive need for intensive inpatient rehabilitation. Compliance is demonstrated through either medical review or the “presumptive” method, in which a patient’s diagnosis codes are compared to a “presumptive compliance” list.    For FY 2014, CMS proposes to remove a number of codes from the “presumptive compliance” list because the described conditions would not prove compliance in the absence of additional facts that would have to be pulled from a patient’s medical record. We have not updated the presumptive methodology policies since 2004, and we welcome comments on this proposal.  

CMS is proposing to revise the list of codes so that it reflects only those codes which can be identified presumptively as both representing the 13 conditions and requiring intensive rehabilitation. The proposed revisions fall in the following categories: non‑specific diagnosis codes, arthritis diagnosis codes, unilateral upper extremity diagnosis, some congenital anomalies diagnosis codes, other miscellaneous diagnosis codes.


PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE IRF QUALITY REPORTING PROGRAM:
Prior-Year Quality Measures. CMS proposes to continue to use the NQF-endorsed National Healthcare Safety Network (NHSN) Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infection (CAUTI) outcome measure that we adopted in the FY 2013 OPPS/ASC PPS final rule. This measure had been updated from a non-endorsed measure we adopted in the FY 2012 IRF PPS final rule. CMS proposes to adopt the NQF-endorsed version of the “Percent of Residents or Patients with Pressure Ulcers that are New or Worsened (Short Stay)” measure, and to stop using the non-risk adjusted version of this measure.  

New Quality Measures. In this rule, CMS is proposing to add three new quality measures to the IRF Quality Reporting Program: NQF #0680: Percent of Residents or Patients Who Were Assessed and Appropriately Given the Seasonal Influenza Vaccine (Short-Stay); NQF #0431: Influenza Vaccination Coverage among Healthcare Personnel; and an All-Cause Unplanned Readmission Measure for an Unplanned Readmission Measure for 30 Days Post Discharge from Inpatient Rehabilitation Facilities.

Proposed Changes to the IRF Patient Assessment Instrument. In order to adopt the NQF-endorsed pressure ulcer measure, which is a risk-adjusted measure, CMS has proposed to revise the IRF-PAI to include the data elements necessary to accommodate risk adjustment. Also, based on feedback CMS received from wound care experts and IRF providers, CMS is proposing to revise the pressure ulcer question set on the IRF Patient Assessment Instrument, in order to better reflect up-to-date medical practice and better assess patients’ needs.  

CMS proposes to add new patient influenza vaccination data elements to the Quality Indicator section of the assessment instrument, and to change the assessment instrument data collection period from a calendar year to a fiscal year. Data that is reported to the National Health Safety Network (NHSN) would continue data collection based on a calendar year period.  

Proposed Reconsideration and Disaster Waiver Processes for Quality Reporting. In this rule, CMS is proposing to implement both a reconsideration and disaster waiver process for Quality Reporting. The reconsideration process would allow IRFs to dispute a finding of non-compliance with quality reporting requirements. The proposed disaster waiver process would allow providers that experienced a natural or man-made disaster to request a waiver of quality reporting requirements under a disaster waiver statute or through the reconsideration process.

The proposed rule went on display at the Office of the Federal Register’s Public Inspection Desk and can be downloaded at:


It will appear in the May 8, 2013 Federal Register. Public comments on the proposals will be accepted until July 1, 2013.

For more information, please see: www.cms.hhs.gov/InpatientRehabFacPPS 

Santorum: Keep fighting Obamacare

May 1, 2013

SAN DIEGO – Some say it’s time for the benefits industry to accept Obamacare — passed by Congress, signed by President Obama, upheld by the Supreme Court — as law.
Rick Santorum is not one of those people.
“I read this morning that someone here was saying, ‘Give up on Obamacare, you can’t do anything to repeal it,’” said Santorum, a keynote speaker at the Benefits Selling Expo Tuesday. “Baloney. Since when do we say, ‘Well, it’s going to happen, might as well give up’?"
Santorum, a former Pennsylvania senator and a GOP presidential candidate in the 2012 election, pointed to Obamacare as a transformative event for the country. The law will fundamentally change Americans’ relationship with their government, he said, and not for the better.

“People are going to now rely on the government in some way for their health insurance,” he said. “And once government has its hand on you, it’s not a matter of you being dependent. It’s a matter of the government having control over you.”
And despite the government intervention, Obamacare will do little to actually improve health care and its costs, Santorum predicted. Giving everyone an insurance card doesn’t mean they’ll be able to afford all the care they need — or, given the nation’s looming primary care doctor shortage, even find it.

“There’s something about an insurance card that makes people feel comfortable, whether it means you can get care or not,” he said.
So, according to Santorum, it’s time for Americans, especially those in industries most affected by Obamacare, to fight back.
“As an industry, to sit back and let the government do this to you, I have three words for you: Shame on you,” he said. “Who’s going to fight for your clients if you don’t? What are you afraid of? You’re going to lose your job anyway if this thing goes into fruition. Go down swinging.”
Santorum asked audience members how many came from a state where the governor or legislature had refused to implement Obamacare. Several dozen hands went up. But when he asked how many of those people had talked to their lawmakers about the decision, most of the hands went back down. That’s the problem, Santorum said.
“They need to hear from you — your congressmen, your legislators,” he said. “If you support what they’re doing, tell them. Because I can guarantee they’re already hearing from the people who don’t.”
Will Santorum be one of those elected leaders again anytime soon? When asked whether he would run for president again, Santorum said only that he was considering his options.
“It’s hard,” he said. “It’s really hard on the family, and that’s the biggest nut for me. When someone asks me if I’m running, my answer is that I’m walking. I’m just walking the right path to see what I can do that’s best for my family and my country.”

Half of 100-Year-Olds Say They Wouldn't Change a Thing About the Way They Lived Their Lives

MINNETONKA, Minn. (May 2, 2013) – A new survey finds that a longer life doesn't necessarily mean a longer list of regrets. When asked what they would have done differently if they knew they would live to 100, 50 percent of centenarians polled in UnitedHealthcare's eighth annual 100@100 survey answered, "not a thing."
Baby boomers ages 60-65 aren't quite so content: only about 1 in 3 (29 percent) say the same thing about their lives so far, while more than a quarter (26 percent) say they wish they had saved more money. Boomers are also more than twice as likely as centenarians to wish they had taken more risks in their lives (12 percent vs. 5 percent).
This year's UnitedHealthcare 100@100 survey polled baby boomers ages 60-65 in addition to centenarians to examine how the attitudes and lifestyles of Americans entering their retirement years compare to those who have held the title of "senior citizen" for 35 years or more. UnitedHealthcare serves more than 12,800 of the estimated 53,000 centenarians nationwide through its portfolio of Medicare plans. The U.S. Census Bureau projects the centenarian population will swell to more than 600,000 by 2050.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average American today lives to be about 80. In view of the "additional years" centenarians have lived compared to peers of their generation, the most senior seniors were asked what could have made these extra years of their lives even better. One-third (33 percent) said nothing: It's as good as they could have hoped for. An equal number (33 percent) wished for more time with their spouse or loved ones. Thirteen percent wished for better health. Only 6 percent said they wish they had more money.
Centenarians are most nostalgic about young adulthood (45 percent), despite the challenges many people associate with this time of life, such as balancing the demands of a career and family. Approaching their 100th birthday was the second most fondly remembered time in centenarians' lives (12 percent).
"The centenarians in this year's 100@100 survey show that maintaining a positive outlook isn't all about focusing on what the future holds," said Dr. Rhonda Randall, chief medical officer of UnitedHealthcare Medicare & Retirement, the nation's largest business dedicated to the health and well-being needs of seniors and other Medicare beneficiaries. "Reflecting fondly and confidently on the choices they've made throughout their lives helps the longest-living Americans maintain a sense of satisfaction and well-being that's vital to healthy aging."
When it comes to expectations for one's own lifetime, nearly 3 in 10 (29 percent) centenarians expected to live to 100. Only about 1 in 5 (21 percent) boomers expects to reach the same milestone.
Centenarians vs. Boomers on Secrets of Physical, Sexual and Emotional Health
Almost all centenarians (98 percent) say that keeping their mind active is a secret to healthy aging, and 100 percent of 60- to 65-year-olds agree. Nearly the same majority (96 percent of centenarians and 98 percent of baby boomers) say that staying mobile and exercising is important. They also agree that physical health is more difficult to maintain as they age, compared with mental health, emotional/spiritual health, social connections and independence.
Despite the difficulty of maintaining their physical health, many centenarians are staying active. More than half say they walk or hike weekly, and more than one-third say they do strength-training exercises at least once a week to stay in shape. Nearly 1 in 5 centenarians say they do a cardio workout indoors one or more times per week.
While nearly all centenarians agree that physical activity is a key to healthy aging, they haven't come to a consensus on the importance of every type of physical activity: only about one-third (31 percent) say that maintaining one's sex life is important. Boomers, on the other hand, are more aligned on this topic. Four in 5 baby boomers (80 percent) agree that maintaining one's sex life is important for healthy aging.
Centenarians and boomers differ on other "healthy habits" as well. Centenarians are more likely than retirement-aged boomers to eat nutritiously balanced meals regularly (86 percent vs. 77 percent), get more than eight hours of sleep each night (66 percent vs. 54 percent), and attend a social event every day (37 percent vs. 28 percent).
The generational differences continue when it comes to some aspects of emotional health. Retirement-aged boomers were more likely than centenarians to say it's very important to continue to look forward to each day (88 percent vs. 72 percent) and to maintain a sense of purpose (79 percent vs. 57 percent).
In Relationships, Centenarians Prefer "Sameness," Boomers Toss Tradition
The secrets to a lasting marriage or life partnership depend on who you ask. Centenarians put a greater premium on "sameness" than 60- to 65-year-olds. More than 3 in 10 centenarians (31 percent) say it is very important to share the same political views as your partner; less than 1 in 5 retirement-aged boomers (19 percent) agree. Nearly twice as many centenarians than boomers say it's very important to have the same hobbies as your partner (40 percent vs. 22 percent). The same pattern holds true for religion - 56 percent of centenarians say partners should share the same faith, compared to 46 percent of boomers.
Boomers are more content to toss tradition aside when it comes to marriage. Less than half say it's very important to maintain the traditional roles of husband and wife (49 percent, vs. 67 percent of centenarians).
Centenarians and boomers are more aligned on the importance of relationships with friends and family. Both generations agree that friends and family have the biggest impact on their lives and provide them with the most support. Nearly everyone surveyed (97 percent of centenarians and 99 percent of boomers) said that staying close to friends and family is a secret to healthy aging. Indeed, more than 1 in 3 centenarians reports maintaining a friendship for more than 75 years.
These long-lasting friendships are especially impressive considering they were maintained largely without the benefit of modern technology that many people rely on to stay in touch with friends and family, such as cell phones, email and social media. A landline phone is still the most popular method of communication for centenarians and boomers, with 90 percent and 94 percent, respectively, reporting that they use it to stay in touch with family and friends. However, nearly half of both groups believe today's communications technologies, such as cell phones, email and text messages, improve relationships by making it easier to stay connected with others.
Centenarians' Positive Self-Reflection Doesn't Extend to Greater Society
While centenarians look back fondly on their own lives, their perspective on the United States and society at large is decidedly less rosy. Nearly 1 in 3 centenarians (and close to half of boomers) surveyed thinks the United States has seen its best days and is on a decline. Additionally, more than 8 in 10 boomers and 6 in 10 centenarians agree with the statement that our society is deteriorating in terms of how we treat one another. Only about 1 in 5 respondents from both groups is more optimistic, saying the United States is continuing to improve and that its best days are yet to come.
When asked to pick from a list, both centenarians and 60- to 65-year-olds chose "respect for elders" and "courtesy" as the top two values they would most like to impart to Millennials in their teens to early 30s. Less than 1 in 10 from either group cited respect for privacy as a top concern.
For Centenarians, Kim Kardashian's Got Nothing on Betty White
Given the opportunity to invite a list of 18 famous people to a family dinner, both centenarians and boomers put Betty White at No. 1 (60 percent and 75 percent, respectively). This is the fourth year in a row that White has topped centenarians' lists.
Centenarians are apparently not "Keeping Up" with Kim Kardashian or friendly toward Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. These young celebrities were among the least likely to make it on centenarians' dinner invite list. In fact, more than half of the centenarians didn't know who these people are.
Of the public figures they are familiar with, centenarians were most likely to say "no" to dinner with Justin Bieber (50 percent), Paul McCartney (49 percent) and Steven Spielberg (48 percent). Topping boomers' "no" lists: Kim Kardashian (87 percent), Justin Bieber (80 percent) and Beyonce Knowles (66 percent).
About the Survey
GfK Roper interviewed 100 centenarians (individuals turning 100 this year or older) and 300 boomers (ages 60-65) by telephone from Feb. 20 to March 12, 2013. Centenarians were interviewed using a list of pre-identified respondents in that age category. Boomers ages 60-65 were selected via a randomly dialed sample derived from probability methods, with pre-identified age ranges. The centenarian sample is not weighted, as population targets for this group are not available. The sample of 60- to 65-year-olds was weighted to reflect their demographics in the U.S. population for this age range. The margin of sampling error for 60- to 65-year-olds is plus or minus 6.7 percentage points for a result of 50 percent at the 95 percent confidence level, for results based on the entire sample of 60- to 65-year-olds. The margin of sampling error is higher and varies for results based on sub-samples.
About UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare is dedicated to helping people nationwide live healthier lives by simplifying the health care experience, meeting consumer health and wellness needs, and sustaining trusted relationships with care providers. The company offers the full spectrum of health benefit programs for individuals, employers and Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries, and contracts directly with 780,000 physicians and other care professionals and 5,900 hospitals and other care facilities nationwide. UnitedHealthcare serves more than 40 million people in health benefits and is one of the businesses of UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH), a diversified Fortune 50 health and well-being company.

Few Small Businesses Are Expected to Drop Health Coverage, Take Penalty Under ACA

By Neal Learner, Editor
April 22, 2013 Volume 4 Issue 8
Most small businesses say they will continue offering health insurance to their employees next year rather than pay a penalty when the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) “employer mandate” kicks in. But as January 2014 approaches, some businesses are starting to finalize tough decisions on how to mitigate the expected cost increases of providing coverage, including by hiring more temporary and part-time workers and moving their operations out of the U.S. entirely, stakeholders tell HRW.
But for now, dropping health insurance appears to be low on that list of options.
According to a February survey of 400 small businesses with 50 or more workers, only 3% of employers said they plan to stop offering health insurance and pay the penalty. Another 71% said they plan to continue offering the coverage, noted the survey by the National Small Business Association (NSBA).
“We aren’t seeing an increase in businesses reporting they plan to opt for the penalty instead of provide insurance, but I think that’s partially driven by the fact that there is still a great deal of information missing about what kind of plan employers will have to offer and its cost,” says Molly Brogan, NSBA’s vice president of public affairs.
“I certainly think many employers are considering all options, but without more information, I think such analyses are increasingly difficult,” she tells HRW.
Under the ACA, businesses with 50 or more workers must offer health insurance to all employees who work an average of 30 hours per week and nine months per year. Alternatively, employers who don’t offer qualified coverage can take a penalty of $2,000 for each employee over a 30-employee threshold. The rules take effect on Jan. 1, 2014.
Many small businesses are still trying to understand how these mandates will affect them, says Brogan.
“I think the first step many are taking is determining if they are deemed to have 50 employees — which, per the law, is a wildly complex calculation including part-time employees, seasonal employees, 12-month look backs, business affiliations and so on — and therefore have to comply with the mandate,” she says. “They’re also trying to figure out if they’re eligible for the tax credit, which is actually pretty limited and only around for a few years. The rest of it is really a waiting game to get more details in terms of what the actual package looks like and costs.”
The Obama administration says the ACA will save small businesses money, and that the tax credit would provide roughly 4 million small firms a total of $40 billion in tax relief over the next 10 years.
But at least one key element of the ACA’s small business initiatives will be pushed back by a year. HHS on March 11 said it was delaying implementation of required multiple plan options under the Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) insurance exchanges, because of “operational challenges.” Starting in 2014, workers at companies with fewer than 100 employees were supposed to have been able to choose from a variety of health plans through the SHOP. Instead, they may be limited to a single plan in most states. The delay applies only to the 33 states where health exchanges will be run by or in partnership with the federal government.
Employers Are Making Hard Calculations
Meanwhile, employers now are crunching the numbers and preparing to make some hard decisions next year, says Joel Allumbaugh, an insurance broker in Maine, and director of the Center for Health Reform Initiatives at the conservative Maine Heritage Policy Center.
He cites an example of a Maine employer who now offers benefits to employees who work 40 hours a week. Because the ACA requires coverage for employees who work 30 hours a week, this business owner suddenly will have to provide health insurance for many more people, he says.
“That’s a pretty significant impact,” Allumbaugh tells HRW. “In those cases, it becomes an economic decision. You start to say, ‘What is it going to cost us to add them to our plan? What is it going to cost us if we just drop the plan altogether?’”
Allumbaugh examined this cost question in a series of cases studies posted on the Center for Health Reform Initiatives website. One centered on a Maine blueberry farm operation that currently provides health coverage for 15 full-time employees, at a total annual cost of $90,540. The company hires an additional 295 seasonal employees, of which 70 would become eligible for coverage in 2014.
Under the first scenario, in which all 70 eligible individuals join the company’s health plan, the costs to the employer would rise by 175% to total $248,985. Under the second scenario in which 35 of the newly eligible take the coverage and another 35 receive subsidies on the exchange, the employer’s health care costs increase by 203% to total $274,762.50 (see table, p. 3). Under the third scenario in which the employer simply stops providing coverage to everyone and takes the $2,000 penalty for each full-time employee (excluding the first 30 employees), the costs drop 16% to total $76,250.
“Unfortunately, that’s the path that is most economically feasible, but it also translates to no longer offering coverage to the 20 people who rely on that coverage,” Allumbaugh says. “So who knows what the impact of that decision might be from an economics standpoint? There’s the issue of attracting and retaining employees.”
Steve Wojcik, vice president of public policy at the National Business Group on Health, notes that surveys have consistently shown that an employer’s health coverage is one of the most valued benefits. But after the ACA passed in 2010, executives and benefits consultants did the calculations to see if it makes sense to drop that coverage, he says.
“People reminded everybody that, ‘hey we’re doing this voluntarily right now, so we’re doing it for a reason and it must be a positive benefit as opposed to just a net cost,’” Wojcik tells HRW.
Employers recognize there are many reasons for providing health coverage, he adds, including two main ones: (1) the tax advantages that go to the employer and the employee, and (2) the likelihood the employers would have to increase compensation if they decided to take the penalty.
Penalty Could Rise Over Time
Wojcik also noted the $2,000 penalty will likely increase over time.
“They’re not going to stay that low,” he says. And once federal officials realize they’ll have to pay for the health care law starting in 2014, “they’ll be looking for revenue sources, and that seems like the most likely one,” he adds.
Others want to kill it altogether. Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) on Feb. 28 introduced legislation to repeal the “employer mandate provision” in the ACA. The American Job Protection Act (S. 399) has 28 co-sponsors and is endorsed by 27 business groups.
The reality of the ACA’s impact on the business community is just now starting to hit home to some business owners, says Allumbaugh, who has been giving presentations on the law’s impact before chambers of commerce across Maine.
“It’s a wake-up call. It’s scary for them,” he says of the many employers who rely on seasonal workers to staff the state’s crucial tourism industry. “There are particular industries that are very concerned and quite frankly should be. It’s going to represent a pretty significant cost impact to them.”
As such, employers are exploring ways they can stay under the ACA’s employer mandate thresholds, including by leveraging variable hours and managing the workforce differently, he notes. But Allumbaugh says one employer is considering drastic measures, and potentially moving his business out of the country.
“Once you identify, ‘Is there going to be a negative impact?’ the next question is, ‘What are we going to do about it?’” he says of these considerations.

Mapping the PPACA world for agents and brokers

April 26, 2013

The outlines of the new “exchanges,” or Web-based health insurance supermarkets, seem to be emerging from the fog of legislation and regulation that has blanketed the U.S. benefits community over the past three years.
The Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight (CCIIO) — the agency setting up the “federally facilitated exchanges” (FFEs) — says it hopes 250,000 producers will register to sell FFE plans.
The Minnesota Health Insurance Exchange hired a marketing agency to study the “need states” that might keep producers from working with the health insurance exchanges, aka “the HIX.”
The managers of Covered California have hired Michael Lujan, a longtime health insurance sales veteran who has written a trade journal article on “how to retain benefits clients,” to woo brokers for their Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) small-group exchange division.
What do the producers think?
Scott Leavitt, a Boise, Idaho, producer who has been president of the National Association of Health Underwriters (NAHU), said he has seen 25 percent of the health insurance producers in his area pull back from the market because of concerns about the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA).

“We’re very scared about what’s going to be coming,” Leavitt said.
Jason Beyrouty, a benefits advisor in the Salem, Ore., office of AKT L.L.P., said the exchange managers in Ore. have been nice to producers. He expects them to continue to be nice to producers — until the flood of applications that comes in during the first exchange open-enrollment period passes.
After that?
“The brokers have a fair amount of fear,” Beyrouty said.
Members of Congress drafted PPACA because the United States is spending more than twice as much on health care as the typical Western European country, getting less access to care for its residents, and ending up with shorter, fatter people who die at a younger age.

PPACA is a huge law with many components. For brokers, one source of PPACA angst is the minimum medical loss ratio (MLR) provision.

Since January 1, 2011, the minimum MLR provision has required insurers to spend at least 85 percent of large-group revenue and 80 percent of individual and small-group revenue on health care or quality improvement efforts.
NAHU and the National Association of Insurance Financial Advisors (NAIFA) contend that customers are the ones who really pay broker commissions and that insurers simply collect the commissions as a convenience to the customers. The producer groups have been lobbying to get Congress to exclude producer compensation from the MLR calculations. Today, producer compensation is still part of MLR calculations, and producers think its driving cuts.
Another PPACA provision that worries brokers, the exchange provision, could start having a direct effect on brokers’ lives October 1, when PPACA requires the exchanges, or Web-based health insurance supermarkets, to start selling individual and small-group coverage.

Tension between insurers and their intermediaries first boiled over in California, in 1993, when an ancestor of the health insurance exchange, the Health Insurance Purchasing Cooperative (HIPC), gave employers that came to it directly a no-broker discount. The HIPC was a miserable failure until 1997, when it eliminated the no-broker discount and became a famous example of why insurance exchanges need brokers.
The builders of the Massachusetts small-group exchange — who were operating in a state with a successful individual exchange program — laughed off the Tale of the Failed HIPC. In 2009, they offered brokers a small-group commission rate of just 2.5 percent of premiums. Commercial insurers were paying commissions of about 3.5 to 4.5 percent of premiums.

Mark Hall, a Wake Forest University law professor who analyzed the program, said managers also used a website that required a broker to enter a huge amount of information just to get a quote, it would then freeze up before it provided the quote.

In February 2010, managers responded to wretched sales by freezing enrollment.

In 2012, when Hall was doing his research, “Connector officials were [still] starting broker training sessions with an apology about past ‘mistakes.’”

The exchange managers are hazy about just how the producer community looks today. FFE officials have suggested in a regulatory filing that there might about 700,000 active U.S. health insurance producers.
A unit of UnitedHealth Group Inc. says in a producer comp discussion on its website that typical base commissions for employer groups with 50 or fewer employees run from 4 percent to 7 percent of premium.

Consultants at Milliman, an actuarial firm, said a large health insurer in California has said that it’s paying commission rates of 8 percent to 12 percent for new individual policy sales and 4 percent to 6 percent of premiums for individual policy renewals.

“Other sources of anecdotal information suggest commissions may be even less than these data points,” the consultants said.

One possible problem: The exchange runners might have inaccurate information about commission rates. In California, the Milliman consultants said, the exchange managers think brokers are getting commission rates of 13 percent to 15 percent for individual policies.

Perry Braun, executive director of the Benefit Advisors Network (BAN), a national benefits firm consortium, said carriers have cut producer comp for some types of business in some markets in half by replacing premium-based commissions with fixed “per member, per month” fees.

Because of the weak economy and the compensation cuts, 21 percent of NAIFA members in the health insurance market have downsized their businesses, according to NAIFA President Robert Smith.
W. Michael Mann of Eustis Benefits, a Metairie, La.,-based benefits consultant, said the typical compensation drop in his area has been only about 10 percent to 15 percent. He has not noticed a mass exodus of health producers. But he has noticed that he is now getting two or three calls per month from agencies that would like to be acquired.

Uncharted seas
In the future, the exchanges might shape producer compensation.

PPACA gives a state the option of setting up an exchange for its residents or letting the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) have CCIIO set up an FFE.

PPACA requires exchanges to offer consumers access to “navigators,” or ombudsmen who are not paid by the health insurers. HHS has said that exchanges will also need “in-person assisters” and possibly other types of registered intermediaries.

B. Hyatt Erstad, a Boise benefits specialist who has been active in NAIFA, said federal regulators seem to be saying reasonable things about how the FFEs might work with producers. “We just haven’t seen anything in writing.”

The FFEs and most state-based exchanges are leaning toward having the exchange insurers pay commissions directly to the producers.

CCIIO officials said commissions for similar products must be similar inside and outside an FFE, but they have not said anything about how high commissions must be.

CCIIO officials have said that the FFEs will work as closely with brokers as state law will allow. In California, Michael Lujan declared at a producer outreach webinar that, “The exchange values the role of the agent.” Managers of the New York exchange have said brokers will be the primary distribution channel for SHOP enrollment.

But, even as the exchange managers court brokers, they are posting proposals describing the fees they might pay navigators and in-person assisters.

Covered California could pay assisters $58 per completed enrollment.

The Washington state exchange could pay a typical navigator firm about $85 per application, with about half of the money going toward general expenses and half being tied to application volume.

State exchanges have indicated that the navigators and in-person assisters will focus mainly on helping low-income consumers enroll in Medicaid plans and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) plans.
Milliman consultants have painted a different picture in their California PPACA premium impact report.
“Currently, broker-driven sales represent a large portion of individual health insurance sales in California,” the Milliman consultants said.

Covered California has predicted that “up to 80 percent of this [individual market] business will transition from the broker distribution channel to the exchange,” the consultants said.

Covered California “estimates that 20 percent of exchange enrollment will be subject to plans paying agents’ commissions and 80 percent will be subject to Covered California paying a fixed ‘certified assisters’ fee,” the consultants said.

HHS says that brokers can’t be navigators, and states are saying that brokers can’t be in-person assisters. Even if brokers could be in-person assisters, they question whether they could provide live human help for just $58 or $85 per application.

Simply helping a well-organized consumer enroll in health coverage over the phone takes about 30 to 45 minutes of agency time, and agency time costs a minimum of about $50 per hour, producers said.
Producers point to the sad end of the PPACA Pre-existing Condition Plan (PCIP) program as a reason to question how reliable the exchanges will be.

Congress allocated $5 billion for the PCIP program to help uninsured people with serious health problems get health coverage before 2014, when a PPACA ban on use of personal health information in underwriting decisions is supposed to take effect.

At first, PCIP managers shut out brokers. In 2011, when PCIP enrollment proved to be embarrassingly low, managers began offering a $100-per-head enrollment fee. In 2012, when sales improved — and PCIP managers discovered that the average annual medical expense of a PCIP enrollee was four times higher than expected — managers axed the $100 enrollment fee.

In February — about 10 months before PPACA is supposed to give sick people access to guaranteed-issue coverage — CCIIO officials suspended the PCIP enrollment process.

A number of producers said they like the idea of exchanges having insurers pay producers directly, rather than the exchange itself paying the commissions.

“That’s a relatively simple process,” Mann said. “The systems are already set up.”

In states with Republican governors, some producers think having their states run state-based exchanges could help. In Idaho, for example, Leavitt and Erstad helped get a state-based exchange bill signed into law.

If Idaho runs its own exchange, “that way, we'll have a voice,” Erstad said.

Braun urged producers to prepare for whatever is coming by being active in industry groups and in producer consortiums.

“I don’t think everybody’s going to suffer the same,” Braun said.

Producers who diversify and get good service from insurers may do better, Braun said.

Now that PPACA is limiting producers’ ability to tinker with the design of a health plan or the price of health coverage, “administration is an important part of brand value,” Braun said.

David Shore, a Boston-area benefits specialist and president-elect of the Massachusetts Association of Health Underwriters, has survived in a state affected by a program that served as a model for PPACA.
“Every state is different,” Shore said. “Any exchange will have a unique set of circumstances.”

But Shore said producers who are preparing to face exchanges should diversify, focus on bigger groups and emphasize fee-based business.

Shore also recommended that producers treat the start of a complicated new health program as a way to get a foot in employers’ doors.

Serving as health program experts “has provided us with a great opportunity to increase our business,” Shore said.

In the long run, Shore said, he expects producers who adapt to change to do well.

“I firmly believe the broker is the least expensive distribution channel in the market today,” Shore said.
Beyrouty said the best proof of brokers’ value is all of the insurers’ and exchanges’ failed attempts to wipe them out.

“If they could have gotten rid of us,” he said, “they would have already done it by now.”

State exchanges have indicated that the navigators and in-person assisters will focus mainly on helping low- income consumers enroll in Medicaid plans and Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) plans.
Simply helping a well-organized consumer enroll in health coverage over the phone takes about 30 to 45 minutes of agency time, and agency time costs a minimum of about $50 per hour, producers said.

Producers point to the sad end of the PPACA Pre-existing Condition Plan program as a reason to question how reliable the exchanges will be.