Thursday, April 25, 2013

Prime, Florida Blue Employ Integrated Strategy to Boost Adherence, Star Ratings

Reprinted from DRUG BENEFIT NEWS, biweekly news, proven cost management strategies and unique data for health plans, PBMs, pharma companies and employers.
By Lauren Flynn Kelly, Editor
April 12, 2013  Volume 14 Issue 7

As CMS continues to place emphasis on medication adherence in its star quality ratings for Medicare Part D plan sponsors, plans that employ an integrated strategy with their PBMs are at an advantage when it comes to boosting adherence, suggested executives from Florida Blue and Blues plan-owned PBM Prime Therapeutics LLC during a recent AIS webinar. Drawing on lessons learned from their own combined experience, speakers advised using targeted and well-timed outreach and communication methods while watching out for barriers to adherence such as cost and patient misconceptions about their medications.
Medicare Part D plans are rated in four domains, which include drug pricing and patient safety. There are four measures related to medication adherence for hypertension, diabetes, high cholesterol and, as of 2013, HIV. Starting in 2012, adherence measures were weighted three times as much as star measures in the other domains, comprising almost half of the aggregate score in general. “So you can see there’s a tremendous amount of focus on adherence measures because of that weighting and the impact to plan sponsors,” explained David Lassen, Pharm.D., chief clinical officer at Prime, speaking at the March 28 AIS webinar, “Medicare Star Ratings: An Integrated Approach to Improving Medication Adherence Measures.”
Based on their experience working together to improve adherence measures, Florida Blue and Prime recommended incorporating the following four elements into an integrated strategy:
(1) Utilize a “joint dashboard” or similarly shared tool to continuously evaluate the measurements and assess the impact of various interventions.
(2) Review on an ongoing basis the communications between all parties involved in supporting the star rating measures.
(3) Conduct pilots and proof of concepts to test and measure more targeted interventions, moving away from a “one-size-fits-all approach,” and determine if there’s something worth rolling out on a broader basis.
(4) Constantly refine engagement activities, comparing and benchmarking various activities (e.g., mail campaigns, automated refill reminder programs) across the board.
When it comes to outreach methods, Cynthia Griffin, Pharm.D., senior director of pharmacy government programs at Florida Blue, advised that both timing and coordination are critical to impacting overall adherence. “I think we’ve learned in health plans over time, the best approach appears to be a holistic one in which the outreach efforts are focused on addressing multiple care gaps with fewer communications,” she observed. “[Members] don’t want to be bombarded with mass communications from their health plans or various vendors representing their health plans.”
In a telephone-based refill reminder pilot conducted in conjunction with Prime, Florida Blue targeted 17,000 members during a 30-day period to ask patients why they are likely to skip a drug. For those who were taking a single drug, 30% responded that they felt they didn’t need the drug. But for patients taking multiple medications, cost replaced “don’t need” as the No. 1 answer (33% versus 25%). The next phase of Prime and Florida Blue’s collaboration will include tailoring interventions based on patient preference and performing a “deeper drill-down” into that “don’t need” category, said Griffin.
Experts Warn Against Free Generic Programs
When discussing the impact of pharmacy benefit design on medication adherence, Lassen pointed out that members utilizing free or $4 generic drug discount programs offered by retailers have the potential to skew data when it comes to tracking adherence. A Prime study released last year was the first to quantify the impact of such programs on a PBM’s ability to conduct and monitor clinical programs (DBN 5/11/12, p. 1).
“We know that member cost-share does have a significant impact on adherence…and the impact of managing generics in this space is also very significant,” he observed. But “ensuring the generic copay for drugs in the star rating adherence measures are at or below common $4 generic cut-points helps otherwise the shifting in members to free generics, which can cause potentially the member to not use their insurance card for processing the prescription and impact the overall star rating measures negatively.” For plans that are considering offering free generic programs of their own, Lassen recommended they “use a targeted approach targeting those [drugs] with star rating measures.”
“Within a given population or region there can be considerable utilization of these programs, and I think the challenge for us as plans is when members vary utilization from month to month,” added Griffin. In other words, a patient may utilize his or her prescription drug benefit one month, and then use one of the free drug programs the next month, leading the plan to view the member as nonadherent. Therefore, it may be necessary to engage case managers and plan pharmacists to work through the process of determining a patient’s overall adherence pattern, she suggested. “And I think it’s really key to engage the member through your overall educational process so that they will understand the impact of various practices.”
Suspecting that such programs were impacting the insurer’s ability to track and manage adherence, Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island conducted an internal analysis to determine that fewer claims were being lost than expected. “It was a little less, but not dramatically less,” says Tara Higgins, R.Ph., clinical pharmacist, who did not speak at the webinar. She explains to DBN that the majority of the Rhode Island Blues plan’s pharmacy contracts employ a “lower of” logic, so if a patient goes into a Walmart and shows his or her insurance card, the member will walk out paying the lower of either the copay amount or the pharmacy’s amount, which is typically $4 for popular generic drugs sold at big-box retailers. Because of the way those contracts are written, the claim would still be captured by the health plan as long as the member presented his or her insurance card.
“I’ve talked to friends that work in the retail setting and I’ve asked them if they ask for the insurance card and they said yes,” reveals Higgins. “The thing that happens is patients believe that they’re not eligible for the program if they present their card. So we have an opportunity to educate members and explain that they’re still eligible for these programs and it’s important for the capturing of the information from a safety perspective [to present the card].”


Today's Datapoint

11 … fewer days on disability (on average) are experienced by employees on short-term disability with a behavioral health condition who have their claims managed by a disability behavioral health unit, according to a study by Aetna Inc.’s Disability and Absence Management Services.

Quote of the Day

“Almost everyone agrees the Medicaid plans in California, which include Health Net and Molina, will realize significant revenue growth from the duals. More controversial is whether they’ll be able to make money from the opportunity. The risk corridor doesn’t guarantee plans make money, but it does limit the potential for big losses.”

— Securities analyst Carl McDonald of Citigroup Global Markets said in a recent research note.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

According to a recent report, from 1999/2000 to 2010/2011:

  • The national percentage of private-sector firms offering employer-sponsored health insurance fell from 58.9% to 52.4%
  • Single-person health insurance premium costs doubled (from $2,490 to $5,081)
  • Family premiums rose 125% (from $6,415 to $14,447)
  • Employee contributions increased (from 17.5% to 20.8% of the total premium)
Source: "State-Level Trends in Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance: A State-by-State Analysis," Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Aprill 11, 2013, http://www.rwjf.org/en/research-publications/find-rwjf-research/2013/04/state-level-trends-in-employer-sponsored-health-insurance.html 

Maryland Offers Glimpse At Obamacare Insurance Math

KHN Staff Writer
Apr 24, 2013
Updated at 5:40 p.m. to add comment from insurers Aetna and UnitedHealthcare.
In the latest preview of prices for health coverage under the Affordable Care Act, Maryland’s dominant insurer says proposed premiums for new policies for individuals will rise by 25 percent on average next year.
That’s lower than what some had predicted. Just three weeks ago, the insurer, CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield, had been looking at a proposed 50 percent increase. But the company revised that initial estimate, citing worries about affordability for consumers.
“Not only were we concerned about a potential hit to subscribers, but we were also concerned about price levels that were unattractive” to young customers seen as an important stabilizing force for the market, CareFirst CEO Chet Burrell said in an interview Wednesday.
Late Tuesday Maryland regulators posted proposed rates and benefits for health plans to be sold through an online exchange,  a step required under the health act, known as the Maryland Health Connection.
Maryland is an important state to watch because it has embraced Obamacare’s insurance reforms, setting up its own marketplace. But there have been serious concerns that the insurance offered there — and on every other exchange across the country — might be too expensive for people to buy.
While most Marylanders younger than 65 have health plans through employers, the exchange’s plans for individuals and small employers are expected to play a key role in bringing coverage to the state’s 700,000 uninsured. That’s about 12 percent of the state’s population.
Many have warned that guaranteeing coverage at regulated prices for sick people would drive up the cost of insurance in the individual market. The ACA prohibits charging sicker members substantially more but allows plans to adjust premiums for age and other factors, within strict limits.
Taking those factors into account, CareFirst premiums for individual plans could rise as high as 150 percent next year for healthy young men and decrease slightly for someone older and sicker, Burrell said.
One current popular CareFirst plan with a $2,700 deductible costs “less than $115 per month” for men under 30, said Mark Hammett, a broker at Kelly & Associates Insurance Group in Hunt Valley, Md.
Consumer advocates were reluctant to draw conclusions from the raw rate filings for the exchange, which make it difficult to quote proposed prices for specific individuals. And they cautioned that filings by CareFirst and other carriers are only preliminary.
“Now the regulators take a look and say, ‘How do you justify these increases?’” said Kathleen Stoll, director of health policy for the pro-ACA consumer group Families USA. “That often results in a reduction to the proposed charges.”
Although prices may rise for some, benefits may be better and many will receive federal subsidies to pay the premiums, she said. Families USA estimates that some 361,000 Marylanders will be eligible for tax credits to pay insurance costs.
“Some people may actually spend much less out of pocket… and end up with a much better product and a much better situation to protect their family from financial devastation from illness,” she said.
That distinction may be initially lost on those focusing only on the premiums, however.
“To the average consumer who has insurance now, the rates will feel every bit like a rate increase,” said Joseph Antos, a health economist at the right-leaning American Enterprise Institute.
CareFirst owns about 70 percent of Maryland’s individual insurance market, with about 120,000 members. Even most of them — 60 percent — won’t see the kind of increases CareFirst proposes because they’re in older, “grandfathered” plans that don’t have to comply with some requirements of the health law yet, Burrell said.
CareFirst and other carriers also filed plans for small employers, but because Maryland had already implemented small-group reforms similar to those that are included in the ACA, those prices weren’t expected to change much. For years Maryland has prohibited insurers from charging substantially more to small employers with sicker and older workforces.
Premiums for CareFirst’s small employer plans to be offered on the exchange next year are proposed to rise about 15 percent, Burrell said, mainly because of the rising cost of health care.
Burrell dismissed a reporter’s suggestion that Democratic Gov. Martin O’Malley, who has much riding on the success of the ACA in Maryland, might have pressured CareFirst to lower its initial filing premiums.
“Nobody asked,” he said. “We did it of our own volition.”
Maryland law requires the nonprofit CareFirst to promote health care affordability and accessibility. With the new, lower projected premiums, Burrell said, “we’re not expecting to make money. We’re expecting to lose money. If we’re going to lose it we’re going to lose it on behalf of subscribers and the community.”
Besides CareFirst, Kaiser Permanente, Aetna, UnitedHealthcare, Coventry Health and Evergreen Health Cooperative all filed to offer about 50 individual or small group plans on the exchange.
An Aetna spokesman said proposed premiums for Maryland small group plans would rise between 12 and 16 percent next year. United proposed average small group increases of from 15 to 28 percent, but premium changes could vary widely depending on the plan, said company spokesman Matt Stearns.
Aetna didn’t say what the average increase for individual plans would be. United hasn’t filed applications yet for Maryland individual plans.
“We currently offer individual coverage in Maryland, and we expect to do so next year,” United's Stearns said.
The O’Malley administration also stressed that the filings are not the final word on insurance prices under the health law.
 “It is premature to reach any judgment or conclusion based on the rates as proposed,” said Carolyn Quattrocki, director of the Governor’s Office of Health Care Reform. “In the meantime, we are pleased that the filings confirm there will be robust participation in the Maryland Health Connection.”
http://www.kaiserhealthnews.org/Stories/2013/April/24/maryland-aca-premiums-carefirst-blue-cross.aspx

Insurers, Distributors Gear Up for Growth In Sales of Ancillary Products in 2014

Reprinted from HEALTH PLAN WEEK, the most reliable source of objective business, financial and regulatory news of the health insurance industry.
By Patrick Connole, Editor
April 15, 2013 Volume 23 Issue 13
Benefits consultants believe that when public health insurance exchanges open in 2014 there will be greater demand from employer-based group plan members and individuals for ancillary insurance products like dental, vision and disability coverage. A top executive for eHealthInsurance Services Inc., an online health insurance marketplace, says health insurers will seek out higher-margin ancillary products to offset what should be a highly competitive major medical market.
“Many of the carriers will offer other products other than major medical, which has become so commoditized with the metal plans, leaving less of a chance to make much money,” Bob Hurley, senior vice president of carrier relations for eHealth, tells HPW. For example, a bronze metal plan, the lowest of the metal tiers, can be supplemented with additional coverage via ancillary products marketed off the public exchanges. “Carriers then can offer a broad area of products to consumers,” he adds.
Carriers also should brand plans inside and outside the exchanges, Hurley stresses, saying ancillary products can assist with branding as well. “I also believe that metal plans may have their own sense of branding. Consumers will get relief that they [metal plans] are certified by the government and will trust in the metals [plans] themselves,” he concludes.
Ancillary products will not be offered on the state exchange Web portal, but are sold on private exchanges and marketplaces like eHealth or directly from a carrier, consultant or broker. Products sold through state and federally facilitated exchanges will be limited to those deemed as meeting essential health benefit requirements.
Christopher Condeluci, of counsel at law firm Venable LLP, tells HPW carriers will be able to make money off major medical plans on public exchanges, but agrees that ancillary offerings will grow in importance and availability. “Carriers can say to consumers, ‘Come to my website and after you buy on the public exchange, buy ancillary products.’ More ancillary products will be sold,” he says. That is because some individuals, even with subsidies, may not be able to afford premiums for richer coverage, so they will get a basic health plan and look to supplement by aggregating other coverage options, Condeluci explains.
Hurley says an analysis by eHealth shows premium increases are going to be fairly significant for young people, but that group may also be the most eligible for subsidies. A 30-year-old single should expect to pay $200 a month for major medical on a public exchange even with a subsidy, and a single 40-year-old around $300 per month, he adds. “We’ll see how it plays out. It is higher than today, but not unheard of in some states in the Northeast where there are essential health benefit-like mandates and guaranteed issue,” Hurley says.
UPMC Readies Products for Private Exchange
UPMC Health Plan (University of Pittsburgh Medical Center) sees major opportunities in 2014 and beyond in attracting customers to ancillary products, partly because several health reform law provisions don’t apply to such products. Unlike medical coverage, the health reform law does not require ancillary products to conform to minimum medical loss ratios (MLR), John Mills, senior director, consumer products for UPMC Health Plan, tells HPW. Under the Affordable Care Act’s MLR requirements, health plans must spend a minimum of 85% of the premiums they receive from large groups to pay for medical costs and a maximum of 15% of these premiums for administrative expenses, or face rebating members. In the individual and small group business, the breakdown is 80% for medical and 20% for administrative expenses. Mills adds that there is also no community rating for ancillary insurance products.
In addition, he says, while major medical coverage costs hundreds of dollars of month, premiums for ancillary products like dental, vision and disability are only in the tens of dollars a month, Mills says.
UPMC will unveil its own private exchange in October with the expectation it will attract members from small to mid-size employers that can set up a defined-contribution platform allowing employees to enroll in whatever type of coverage they want. Mills says a lot of larger employers are already using private exchanges offered by Aon Hewitt, Buck Consultants, Mercer and Towers Watson, among others (HPW 2/14/13, p. 1). Thus UPMC expects middle to smaller group markets to be the most active on UPMC’s new exchange, in addition to individual purchasers.
Employers that are not able to offer their workers multiple plan choices through a defined-contribution benefit design, but that don’t want to abandon group coverage altogether, will be able to purchase ancillary products that may not be available currently from the employer plan.
Reform Law Spurs Ancillary Trade
Mary Drueke, vice president of employee benefits with Omaha, Neb.-based Swartzbaugh-Farber & Associates, Inc., a United Benefit Advisors (UBA) partner firm, tells HPW that health reform changes will fuel greater interest in ancillary insurance. “One of the main ways before to attract and retain employees was through maintaining medical insurance, but because of the removal of pre-existing conditions [exclusions], it will now be attractive to offer other services,” she says.
UBA released a preliminary survey on ancillary products in late March that said as “health care exchanges go online and fewer businesses are burdened with a full health care plan, an interest in ancillary employee benefits products continues to grow.” UBA got responses from nearly 12,000 employers, which showed that nearly three-quarters of all employers responding offered employees dental coverage, with almost all large employers providing the benefit.
Nearly all businesses with more than 500 employees said they offered group term life insurance, but only 56% with fewer than 50 workers did. “An industry breakdown of short-term disability coverage shows that 37% of employers responding in all major industries offer the coverage. Eight percent of employers with 1,000-plus employees offer pet insurance, but less than .5% of smaller employers with less than 200 employees included it in their benefits packages,” the study said.

Are the Wheels Falling Off the Federal Exchange Bus?

By Steve Davis - April 23, 2013
Over the past month, HHS pushed some insurance exchange elements to the back burner — or off the stove completely — until 2015. Given tight deadlines to start up exchanges and the federal data hub, it’s not surprising that HHS is focusing on just that — and delaying some nonessential elements. But what else might be delayed? And will exchanges, navigators, in-person assisters and the data hub all be ready to enroll the previously uninsured on Oct. 1?
Last month, HHS indicated it would delay a key feature of the Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) in federally facilitated and state-partnership exchanges. The feature would allow employees to choose from a menu of health plan options in each metal tier. With the exception of employers eligible for the small-employer tax credit, it won’t make much sense for employers to get coverage through a public exchange in 2014.
But state-run exchanges are another story. HHS gave state exchanges the option of delaying the choice feature until 2015 or moving ahead as planned. But nearly every state exchange director I contacted told me they intended to stay the course.
And early this month, CMS told agents and brokers that they would not have access to a dedicated Web portal for selling coverage through federally facilitated and partnership exchanges, as was envisioned. The portals were to be producer-specific websites where brokers could offer clients side-by-side comparisons of plans offered through an exchange. CMS explained to industry trade groups that it didn’t have the resources needed to get the portals up and running in time for the start of the enrollment season. The delay does not apply to state-run exchanges.
Officials from two trade groups — the Independent Insurance Agents & Brokers of America and the National Association of Health Underwriters — told me they were surprised and disappointed by the decision. The advantage of selling coverage through an exchange is it gives brokers and their clients a way to look at multiple plan options. The portal also would have made it easier for agents and brokers to manage policies throughout the plan year.